Ashutosh Gowariker’s ‘Mohenjo Daro’ Falls Prey to Hindutva Horseplay

Post on : 2016-07-05 14:13:31

The Hindu right’s worn-out, archaeologically-baseless argument that the Harappan civilisation and Rig Vedic age coincided, may get a new lease of life through the film’s poor depiction of history.



It seems that Ashutosh Gowariker’s quest for good cinema ends with humongous sets and big stars. While there seems to be a sudden – and welcome – urge among Hindi filmmakers to make historical epics, their lack of attention to historical facts leaves the discerning audience with a bad taste in the mouth. Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s Bajirao Mastani recently portrayed Bajirao as an indefatigable Hindu warrior, one whose only mission was to hoist the saffron flag in India by defeating his Muslim opponents, the Mughals. That the modern Indian state was yet to be born and that the Mughal empire was no caliphate, are facts disregarded by him.



Yet again, a historical film seems to be catching public attention, but for all the wrong reasons.

Gowariker, of Lagaan (2001) and Jodhaa Akbar (2008) fame, recently released the trailer of his much-awaited Mohenjo Daro, which is being touted as not just his magnum opus but the greatest film ever made in India. Unfortunately, the trailer gives us nothing but a twisted idea of a civilisation that seems far from real. Mohenjo Daro, which was the name of one of the biggest urban townships of the Harappan or Indus Valley civilisation, is the story of one of the first cities of the world. Gowariker gets the date right – 2016 BCE, which the trailer announces – but apart from this, he gets almost every other aspect of the ancient civilisation grossly wrong.



The use of heavily Sanskritised Hindi in the trailer leads one to believe that a similar dialect was spoken around that time. There is no disclaimer to the contrary. Professional historians, archaeologists and Indologists alike have argued that multiple dialects of the Bronze age were possibly in use during the Indus Valley civilisation, or that it could have been a nonlinguistic civilisation. At any rate, there is hardly any evidence for a Sanskrit-based, spoken or written, language; this was something that evolved much later.

Hollywood stunt master for Akhil Too!
Pre-production for Akhil and director Vikram Kumar has begun. Vikram Kumar of 'Ishq', 'M
2017-03-04 16:57:23
Pooja Hegde to be seen as NRI in DJ!
Allu Arjun's 'DJ Duvvada Jagannadham', that is being directed by Harish Shanka
2017-03-04 16:54:52
Date fixed for Akhil's second movie launch
Akhil Akkineni's second film has got a launch date. The film will be launched on the 1st of Apri
2017-03-04 16:52:05
Rashi Khanna turns poet
Rashi Khanna is penning her thoughts. As Women's Day is fast approaching the actress has penned
2017-03-04 16:49:21
Pizza 2 girl terms SuchiLeaks not true!
A huge controversy happened when a singer and RJ Suchitra posted private pictures of some actors and
2017-03-04 16:47:10
Directing 'Rogue' was new experience for Puri
Telugu director Puri Jagannadh is ready with his new film, and he is nervous. He says directing &quo
2017-03-04 16:44:36
Ravi Teja keen to play negative roles
Actor Ravi Teja, best known for his films such as "Kick" and "Don Seenu", says h
2017-03-04 16:38:01
Sharwanand signs Raghavendra Rao's son's movie
Sharwanand is on a roll. The actor who will be releasing 'Radha' later this month is already
2017-03-04 16:31:02